Could Your Back Pain Actually Be Coming from Your SI Joint?

Is Your Lower Back Pain Actually SI Joint Pain? Symptoms, Causes, and Treatment Options

Columbia Orthopaedic Group spine surgeon Dr. Craig Meyer explains this often-overlooked cause of lower back pain, how to recognize the symptoms, and which treatments may help.

When you're dealing with persistent lower back pain, it's natural to assume the problem is coming from your spine. But what if the actual source of your discomfort is somewhere else?

For some patients, the problem isn't the lumbar spine. It's the sacroiliac joint, commonly called the SI joint, located where the base of your spine meets your pelvis.

Dr. S. Craig Meyer, an orthopaedic spine surgeon at Columbia Orthopaedic Group, explains that SI joint pain can closely resemble other conditions, including lumbar disc problems, hip arthritis, and sciatica.

Understanding the difference is essential to finding the right treatment.

What Is the Sacroiliac (SI) Joint?

The sacroiliac joints connect the sacrum, the triangular bone at the bottom of your spine, to your pelvis. There is one SI joint on each side of the body.

These joints help support your weight and transfer forces between your upper body and legs.

Unlike your hips or knees, SI joints have very limited movement. However, even small amounts of motion can contribute to discomfort.

As Dr. Meyer explains, "But it moves enough that it will create or be a cause of your pain."

Like other joints, the SI joint contains cartilage and can experience degeneration or inflammation over time.

How Common Is SI Joint Pain?

SI joint pain may be more common than many people realize.

Research discussed by Dr. Meyer suggests that approximately 15% to 30% of patients experiencing chronic lower back pain may have pain originating from the SI joint.

For individuals who have undergone certain lumbar fusion procedures, that percentage may be higher.

This distinction matters because treating the lumbar spine alone may not relieve discomfort when the SI joint is the actual source.

What Are the Symptoms of SI Joint Pain?

SI joint pain can resemble several other conditions, but certain symptoms may provide important clues.

Common signs include:

  • Lower back or buttock pain: Often concentrated on one side, near where the spine meets the pelvis.
  • Pain when sitting: Prolonged sitting can increase discomfort.
  • Pain when standing up: Moving from sitting to standing may aggravate symptoms.
  • Difficulty sleeping on one side: Lying on the affected side may cause pain.
  • Pain radiating into the leg: Discomfort may resemble sciatica.
  • Hip or groin pain: Symptoms can overlap with other hip conditions.

Dr. Meyer identifies sitting discomfort as one particularly useful clue.

"Patients who have SI pain, I usually tell people it's more of a sitting problem."

Another helpful observation is the Fortin Finger Test. Patients with SI joint pain can often point to a specific painful area near the joint using one finger.

Although these patterns may suggest SI joint dysfunction, a medical evaluation is needed to confirm the cause.

SI Joint Pain vs. Lower Back Pain: What's the Difference?

Determining whether discomfort originates in the SI joint, lumbar spine, or hip isn't always straightforward.

As Dr. Meyer notes, "And again, there's a lot of overlap between SI pain, lumbar spine pain, and hip pain."

For example, SI joint discomfort can resemble sciatica, particularly when pain travels into the buttock or leg.

Likewise, patients experiencing chronic lower back pain may assume they have a lumbar spine problem when the SI joint is contributing to their symptoms.

Some patients have imaging studies showing no significant spinal abnormalities despite persistent pain.

The goal is not simply determining where someone hurts, but identifying which structure is causing the discomfort.

What Causes Sacroiliac Joint Pain?

SI joint pain can develop for several reasons, including:

Joint degeneration: Age-related changes and wear can affect the cartilage and surrounding structures.
Falls and injuries: Falls involving the buttocks or certain motor vehicle accidents may stress the joint.
Pregnancy: Changes in the pelvis and supporting tissues can contribute to SI joint discomfort, particularly during the third trimester.
Previous lumbar fusion: Spinal fusion may change how forces are transferred through the lower back and pelvis, potentially placing additional stress on the SI joint.

For patients experiencing persistent pain after spinal surgery, evaluating the SI joint may be particularly important.

How Is SI Joint Pain Diagnosed?

Because symptoms overlap with other conditions, Dr. Meyer emphasizes using several diagnostic methods.

Medical history: Understanding where pain occurs, what triggers it, and whether previous injuries or surgeries may contribute.

Physical examination: Specialized maneuvers place controlled stress on the SI joint to determine whether they reproduce familiar symptoms.

Diagnostic imaging: X-rays and MRI studies may identify lumbar spine or hip abnormalities. However, SI joint pain doesn't always produce obvious imaging findings.

Diagnostic SI joint injections: Numbing medication is injected into the joint to determine whether temporarily blocking pain provides significant relief.

Dr. Meyer describes diagnostic injections as "the gold standard in diagnosing SI pain."

If the injection substantially reduces the patient's familiar discomfort, it strengthens the evidence that the SI joint is responsible.

Can SI Joint Pain Be Treated Without Surgery?

Yes. Many patients begin with nonsurgical treatments before considering an operation.

Common options include:

  • Physical therapy: Exercises to improve strength, stability, and movement.
  • Anti-inflammatory medications: May help manage discomfort when medically appropriate.
  • SI joint belts: Supportive devices worn around the pelvis to provide additional stability.
  • SI joint injections: Corticosteroid injections that may provide temporary or longer-lasting relief.
  • Radiofrequency ablation: A procedure targeting nerves that transmit pain signals from the SI joint.

Columbia Orthopaedic Group offers specialized pain management services to help patients explore appropriate nonsurgical treatment options.

While some patients achieve meaningful improvement through these approaches, others continue experiencing significant pain.

When Is Minimally Invasive SI Joint Fusion Considered?

For patients with persistent SI joint pain despite appropriate nonsurgical treatment, minimally invasive SI joint fusion may be an option.

Dr. Meyer generally considers surgery after conservative treatments have been attempted and diagnostic testing supports the SI joint as the primary source of pain.

The procedure uses specially designed implants to stabilize the joint and support fusion.

Dr. Meyer has extensive experience with minimally invasive SI joint fusion and has participated in clinical research evaluating these procedures.

Studies discussed by Dr. Meyer have reported favorable outcomes in approximately 80% to 90% of appropriately selected patients undergoing certain minimally invasive fusion techniques.

However, individual outcomes depend on diagnosis, medical history, previous surgeries, and other factors.

An evaluation by Columbia Orthopaedic Group's spine surgery specialists can help determine whether surgery is appropriate.

What Is Recovery Like After SI Joint Fusion?

Minimally invasive SI joint fusion is generally performed as an outpatient procedure.

Dr. Meyer notes that surgery itself often takes approximately 30 minutes, although patients spend additional time at the surgery center.

Following surgery, patients typically use crutches or a walker while limiting weight-bearing on the affected side.

Around three weeks after surgery, Dr. Meyer reevaluates patients and obtains imaging to assess their progress.

Activity can gradually increase based on healing. Higher-impact activities, including running and jumping, may remain restricted for approximately four to six months.

Recovery varies by patient, making it important to follow individualized postoperative instructions.

Frequently Asked Questions About SI Joint Pain

Can SI Joint Pain Feel Like Sciatica?
Yes. SI joint pain can radiate into the buttock and leg, creating symptoms similar to sciatica.

Does SI Joint Pain Show Up on an MRI?
Not always. Physical examinations and diagnostic injections may help identify SI joint pain even when imaging doesn't reveal significant abnormalities.

Can SI Joint Pain Develop After Back Surgery?
Yes. Previous lumbar fusion can change how forces move through the spine and pelvis, potentially contributing to SI joint discomfort.

Can SI Joint Pain Improve Without Surgery?
Yes. Physical therapy, medications, SI joint belts, injections, and radiofrequency ablation may help manage symptoms without surgery.

Find Answers to Persistent Lower Back Pain

Living with persistent lower back pain can make everyday activities, from sitting comfortably to getting a good night's sleep, increasingly difficult.

Dr. Meyer's approach focuses on identifying the actual source of discomfort before determining which treatments may help.

If you've been experiencing unexplained lower back, hip, or buttock pain, the SI joint may be one of several possible causes worth evaluating.

Watch the Full SI Joint Pain Webinar

Want to learn more about SI joint symptoms, diagnosis, and treatment options?

Watch Dr. Meyer's educational presentation, where he discusses SI joint dysfunction, nonsurgical treatments, minimally invasive fusion, recovery, and answers common patient questions.

>> Watch the Full Webinar: Understanding SI Joint Pain

Schedule a Consultation at Columbia Orthopaedic Group

At Columbia Orthopaedic Group in Columbia, Missouri, our specialized orthopaedic teams help patients identify the source of their discomfort and explore appropriate treatment options.

Ready to get answers about your back pain?

Schedule a consultation or call 573-876-8141.

This article is intended for educational purposes and does not replace individualized medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment.